Brother's Pizzeria Menu (2025 Update)

Introducing the menu at Brother's Pizzeria, located in Staten Island, NY, this pizzeria offers a wide variety of options including salads, steak fries, and cheeseburgers. Customers rave about the Sicilian slice, with perfect crust, sauce, and cheese. The establishment prides itself on quick service and a friendly staff. Specialties like chicken rolls, vodka squares, and buffalo chicken rolls receive high praise. While some customers note occasional inconsistencies in the finished product, Brother's Pizzeria remains a favorite for its delicious pizzas and generous portions. With options for vegetarians and a casual atmosphere perfect for families and groups, Brother's Pizzeria is a must-visit for pizza lovers in the area.